Bird and Plant Identification Flashcards: Learning Species From Photos
One photo per species teaches you that photo, not the bird. How to build ID cards with several images, confusing pairs, and field marks that work outdoors.
The biggest mistake with species identification flashcards is using one photo per species. If every review of the song sparrow shows you the same picture, you will learn to recognize that picture very quickly. Then you go outside, the bird is turned the other way, the light is grey, and it is half hidden in a bush, and you have nothing, because you never learned the bird. You learned the photo. So the cards that actually work outdoors use several different photos of each species, are organized around the confusing pairs, and put the field marks on the back so you know what you were supposed to be looking at.
(This guide is from the Nebulearn blog. Nebulearn makes a flashcard app, but for birds and plants there are excellent free tools built just for this, and they are covered at the end.)
The photo problem
Here is what usually happens. You decide to learn the twenty most common birds where you live. You find a nice photo of each one, make twenty cards, and review them for a week. By the end of the week you are getting all twenty right in a second or two, and you think, "great, I know my local birds."
Then you go for a walk. A small brown bird lands on a fence. You look at it and you think, "that is... a sparrow, I think? Which one?" You can see that it is brown and streaky, but you have no idea which features matter, because on your card you recognized the whole picture at once. Maybe it was the background, or the pose, or the exact shade of brown in that one photo. You never had to notice that one sparrow has a central breast spot and another does not.
This is a common issue with image cards in general, and encoding diagrams effectively describes it: if the same image always appears, you can learn a shortcut that does not transfer. For identification it is worse, because the real world never shows you the same image twice.
Several photos per species
The fix is to give each species several photos, and have the card show a different one each time. There are two ways to do that, depending on your app.
One card per photo. Make three to six cards for each species, each with a different photo on the front and the same name on the back. This works anywhere, including on paper. The downside is that a common species ends up with six cards in your daily reviews, but those cards get easy quickly, so it is not much extra time.
One card that changes its photo. Some apps can randomly show one of several images on the front. This is tidier, but not all apps can do it.
Whichever you choose, choose the photos on purpose. You want variety in exactly the things that vary outdoors:
| Vary this | Why |
|---|---|
| Angle (front, side, back, from below) | You will rarely see the bird or plant in the pose a field guide uses |
| Lighting (bright, overcast, backlit) | Colours look completely different in grey light |
| Sex and age (male, female, juvenile) | In many birds these look like different species |
| Season (breeding and winter plumage, flowering and not flowering) | A plant without its flowers is a different identification problem |
| Distance (close, far, partly hidden) | Most real sightings are not frame filling |
| The part you actually see (for plants: leaf, bark, flower, fruit, whole plant) | You often only get one of these |
For plants especially, the last row matters most. A tree in winter has no leaves. A wildflower before it blooms is just leaves. If you want to identify a plant all year, you need cards of the leaf, the bark, and the overall shape, not only the flower.
Put the field marks on the back
On the back of each card, below the name, write the two or three features that tell you it is this species. Birders call these field marks.
Front: A photo of a small brown streaky bird on a branch.
Back: Song Sparrow. Heavy brown streaks that gather into a central spot on the breast. Long rounded tail. Grey face with brown stripes.
This does two things. When you get it right, it confirms that you were looking at the right features and not guessing from the background. When you get it wrong, it tells you exactly what to look for next time, which is what you need. Over a few weeks, you will start looking for those features automatically, and that is the skill that works outdoors.
Keep it to two or three features. A paragraph of description on the back turns into reading, and you will skim it. That is the atomic encoding rule again, and it matters here because the whole point is to learn which few features to look for.
Build the deck around confusing pairs
Most of the difficulty in identification is not individual species. It is pairs and small groups that look alike. Downy woodpecker and hairy woodpecker. Cooper's hawk and sharp-shinned hawk. Poison ivy and the many harmless three leafed plants it gets confused with. House finch and purple finch.
For each confusing pair, add a comparison card:
Front: Downy woodpecker vs hairy woodpecker: how do you tell them apart?
Back: Bill length. Downy has a short bill, much shorter than its head. Hairy has a long bill, about as long as its head. Hairy is also noticeably bigger.
And when you choose photos for the regular cards of each pair, try to pick ones that make the distinguishing feature visible, so that your reviews are practicing the exact comparison you need. Then mix all the cards together, so you never know which of the pair is coming. If all your woodpecker cards are in a woodpecker folder and you only review them one after another, it is much easier than meeting one at random, which is how it will be outdoors. There is more on why mixing helps in studying two subjects with interleaving.
Where to get photos you are allowed to use
This is worth a moment, because it is easy to just save images from a search. If the deck is only for you, privately, that is a grey area most people do not worry about. But if you plan to share your deck with a class, a club, or anyone else, use photos you have the right to share.
Good sources are your own photos (the best kind, since they show what you actually see, in your actual light), and photos with Creative Commons licenses. Many of the photos on iNaturalist and on Wikimedia Commons have licenses that allow reuse, often with credit. Check the license on each image and add the photographer's name in the card or the deck description if it asks for one.
Birds by sound
For birds, much of identification is by sound, not sight. In a forest in spring, you will hear many more birds than you will see. If that matters to you, make sound cards: a short audio clip of the song on the front, the name and a short description of the song on the back.
The same rule about variety applies. One recording per species teaches you that recording. Use a few, from different individuals, since birds of the same species often sing slightly different versions. Sound cards behave a lot like music interval flashcards, where the trick is also to hear the same thing in many slightly different forms. For the description on the back, many birders use words that sound like the song, like "drink your tea" for the eastern towhee. Those are a kind of memory trick, and mnemonics on flashcards covers how to use them well.
The free field tools come first
For birds and plants, the free dedicated tools are excellent, and they belong alongside any flashcard deck.
Merlin, from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, can identify birds from a photo or from sound as they sing near you, and it is free. eBird, from the same lab, shows you which species have been seen near you recently, which is the best way to decide what to put in your deck. iNaturalist lets you upload photos of anything living and get help from the community identifying it, and it is a great source of photos of local species in real conditions. For bird songs specifically, there are paid apps built around learning songs with spaced practice, and they are a very good choice if sound is your main goal.
And nothing replaces going outside. Every bird or plant you identify on a walk is a retrieval that no card can match, because it has all the mess and variety of the real thing. The cards are what get you to the point where those walks start to make sense.
Where a flashcard app like Anki or Nebulearn helps is keeping a growing deck of species reviewed on a schedule, so the ones you know well stop coming up every day and the confusing pairs come up more. In Nebulearn you can add photos to cards, and image occlusion is useful for plant parts, like labeling the parts of a flower or the features of a leaf. FSRS is on by default.
Learn the species, not the photo
Identification is learning a species, not a picture. Use several photos per species, varied in exactly the ways nature varies them, and write the field marks on the back so you learn what to look at. Organize the deck around confusing pairs, mix everything together, start with the species you will actually see, and then go outside as often as you can.