Back to blog

The Learning Styles Myth: Why Being a "Visual Learner" Does Not Change How to Study

Matching lessons to visual, auditory or kinesthetic styles has not held up in research. What actually works instead, and why the content should pick the format, not you.

The idea that each person has a learning style, visual, auditory or kinesthetic, and learns best when lessons match it, is one of the most popular ideas in education and one of the least supported by evidence. People really do have preferences. You might genuinely prefer diagrams over lectures. But when researchers test whether teaching people in their preferred style makes them learn more, the answer keeps coming back as no, or as an effect too small to matter. What does make a big difference is matching the format to the content, and using study methods that work for everybody, like testing yourself and spacing your reviews.

(This is the Nebulearn blog, and Nebulearn makes a flashcard app.) None of this says your preferences do not matter. They matter for motivation. They just do not seem to change how your memory works.

Where the idea comes from

There are many learning style models, dozens of them, but the most famous one in schools is VARK, developed by Neil Fleming in New Zealand. It sorts people into visual, auditory, reading and writing, and kinesthetic learners, based on a questionnaire. The broader idea of visual, auditory and kinesthetic styles, often shortened to VAK, has been around even longer.

Many people took a quiz like this in school. You answered questions like, "When you want to learn how to use a new piece of software, do you prefer to read the manual, watch a video, or just try it?" Then you got a result: "You are a visual learner." And from then on, you might have been told to make colourful mind maps, or to listen to recordings, depending on your result.

It is easy to see why the idea is appealing. It feels personal. It respects that people are different. And it gives teachers and students something concrete to do. Surveys have found that a large majority of teachers in many countries believe in it. Many students do too.

What the research actually tested

The key claim is not that people have preferences. Everyone agrees they do. The key claim is something researchers call the meshing hypothesis: that people learn better when instruction matches their style. A visual learner taught visually should learn more than a visual learner taught by listening, and an auditory learner should show the opposite pattern.

In 2008, a group of cognitive psychologists, Harold Pashler, Mark McDaniel, Doug Rohrer and Robert Bjork, reviewed the research on this. They pointed out that to really test the meshing hypothesis, you need a specific kind of experiment: sort people by style, randomly teach each group in different styles, and test them all the same way. Then you check whether the match helps.

They found that very few studies had used that design, and among the ones that had, the results mostly did not support the hypothesis. Some found no effect. Some found the opposite of what the theory predicts. Their conclusion was that there was no adequate evidence to justify using learning style assessments to guide teaching.

Since then, more studies have tested this directly, and the results have mostly held. For example, a study of anatomy students by Polly Husmann and Valerie Dean O'Loughlin found that students who took the VARK quiz generally did not study in the way that matched their style, and those who did were not getting better grades for it. Other reviews have reached similar conclusions.

So why does it feel true?

If you think of yourself as a visual learner, you probably have real experiences behind that. A diagram made something click that a lecture did not. You remember faces better than names. Those experiences are real. But there are better explanations for them than a fixed learning style.

Some content is visual. A diagram of the heart is easier to understand than a paragraph describing the heart, for almost everyone. That is not because you are a visual learner. It is because the heart is a physical object with a shape. A map is better than a list of directions for the same reason.

Some people are better at some things. Some people have stronger spatial skills, or a richer vocabulary. That affects how easily they learn certain material, but it is about ability with that kind of material, not a general style.

Preference affects effort. If you like diagrams, you might spend more time looking at them carefully, which helps. That is a real effect, but it comes from engagement, not from your brain needing a specific format.

We remember the successes. When a diagram helps, we remember it and think, "I am a visual learner." When a diagram did not help, we do not think, "I guess I am not a visual learner after all."

What matters instead: the content picks the format

The idea that has much better evidence behind it is that the best format depends on what you are learning, not who you are.

ContentBest format, for almost everyoneWhy
Anatomy, geography, chemical structuresDiagrams, images, labeled picturesThe content is spatial
Pronunciation, music, language listeningAudioYou need to hear the sounds
Lab skills, sports, instruments, surgeryDoing it, hands onThe skill is physical
Arguments, history, lawReading and writingThe content is built from language
Processes and cyclesDiagrams plus wordsBoth the sequence and the meaning matter
Maths and physicsWorked examples, then problemsYou learn procedures by doing them

So if you are learning the bones of the hand, use labeled images, whatever your "style." Encoding diagrams effectively covers how to make those work. If you are learning Spanish pronunciation, listen to it, whatever your "style." And if you are learning to play the guitar, practice on a guitar, though flashcards still help with the fretboard itself, as guitar fretboard flashcards shows.

There is also good evidence for combining words and pictures, which researchers call dual coding. Allan Paivio proposed it, and Richard Mayer's research on multimedia learning built on it. The idea is that when information comes in through both words and images, you have two ways to remember it. This helps everyone. Not only visual learners, everyone.

The methods that work for everyone

If learning styles are not the key, what is? The research on learning strategies points to a small number of methods that help almost everybody, across subjects and ages. A big review by John Dunlosky and colleagues in 2013 rated common study techniques, and two came out clearly on top:

Practice testing. Testing yourself, with flashcards, practice questions, or a blank page, rather than rereading. This works partly because the act of pulling information out of your memory strengthens it. See active recall vs spaced repetition and blank sheet retrieval practice.

Distributed practice. Spreading your studying out over time, rather than cramming it into one session. This is what spaced repetition does, as what is spaced repetition explains.

Some other strategies were rated as promising, like explaining things to yourself and mixing different types of problems. And some very popular ones, like highlighting and rereading, were rated as low usefulness. Why you can't remember what you read explains why rereading fools you. Notice that none of these are about learning styles. They work whether you call yourself visual, auditory or kinesthetic.

Does it hurt to believe in learning styles?

Mostly, believing in learning styles is harmless in itself. The harm comes from what it can lead to.

If you believe you are an auditory learner, you might avoid diagrams, even for anatomy, where a diagram is clearly the right tool. If you believe you are a kinesthetic learner, you might decide that reading is just not for you, when reading is a skill you could get better at. If a teacher sorts their class by style and teaches each group differently, that takes time and effort that could have gone into methods that actually work for everyone.

The most important harm is the belief that "I learn differently, so the usual advice does not apply to me." Practice testing and spacing do apply to you. They apply to almost everyone.

Where your preferences still matter

None of this means preferences are useless. If you enjoy making colourful diagrams, and it keeps you studying, keep making them. If you like listening to recorded lectures on walks, and it means you go over the material more often, great. Motivation is real, and anything that makes you study more without replacing better methods is a good thing.

Just make sure the preference is not stopping you from testing yourself. A beautiful mind map you never quiz yourself on is still just rereading. A recorded lecture you listen to three times is still passive. The trick is to add self testing on top of whatever format you prefer.

Further reading

If you want to go deeper, the 2008 review by Pashler and colleagues is surprisingly readable and is the standard reference. Daniel Willingham, a cognitive psychologist, has written widely about learning styles for teachers and the general public, and his book Outsmart Your Brain is a practical guide to study strategies. The Learning Scientists website has free, clear explanations of the strategies with good evidence.

Flashcards, including in an app like Nebulearn or Anki, are mostly a tool for the two methods that work for everyone: practice testing and spacing. In Nebulearn, you can put images, text, and image occlusion on cards, so the format can follow the content, and FSRS handles the spacing. But whatever tool you use, let the material decide the format, not a quiz you took in school.

Let the material pick the format

People have preferences, but the evidence that matching teaching to a learning style helps you learn more is very weak. What matters more is matching the format to the content, pictures for spatial things, sound for sounds, practice for skills, and using methods that work for everyone, like testing yourself and spacing out your reviews. Keep the formats you enjoy, and add self testing on top.

Learning StylesLearning ScienceStudy TipsMyths